Search This Site.

Unusual Temp Agency and Unemployment Benefits

by Carol

Hi Chris,

This is rather long. In June 2009, my boss placed me and 2 other employees on CA workshare unemployment. My hours were cut by 50%. After the first year, workshare was extended in June 2010 for another year. In October 2010, a friend said his company (MC) needed help and asked me to come work as a freelancer. I agreed; by that time, my hours had gone from 20/wk down to 0, and I was freelancing 10-12 hrs/wk at one place and collecting partial benefits. My boss and I discussed it and he agreed to lay me off (with a written letter) because the other 2 workers no longer submitted their worksheets (because their work hours increased for their type of work); so technically, I no longer qualified for workshare. I did not call CA EDD to let them know I was now 100% unemployed, but had found freelance work.

At MC, I was told that I would need to submit paperwork with their internal employment agency. (As I understood it, the agency would take care of my taxes so that MC could employ me without penalty from the IRS). But I was still considered an independent contractor (as the agency's website called us).
My assignment ends at the end of the month which would make it 3.5 mos. Yesterday, the manager met with me and said they couldn't afford to hire anyone at this time, so there was no job offer on the table. But she wanted to discuss my skills, and she asked if I'd be interested in doing the same work in the future (as a full-time employee). If so, she would put my name on a list of recommended candidates for future hires, and it would be ideal for MC because they would not have to pay the fee to "buy you out of the contract like other temp agencies" because I was a freelancer brought in by my friend, not a temp agency. I said I enjoyed freelancing; and she took it that I wasn't interested in full-time work, but they could still use me as a freelancer. I didn't want to say "Yes" when the truth is, because the tasks were so redundant, I was starting to doze off at
my desk. We talked a bit more and the meeting ended. Afterwards, my friend asked about the meeting and I gave him a brief update. Later I noticed his supe talking with him, and I heard him say regarding me, "by her own choice". He's a nice guy and I don't believe he meant any harm.

Over the past weeks, I had purposely asked how long they intended to use me so if I applied for UI after the assignment (because I couldn't find new freelance work), it was due to MC's termination, not mine. Now, by saying I enjoyed freelancing, it might sound like I terminated the assignment, not MC. And the manager's statement about the buy-out made me wonder because the agency's website didn't mention that they lined up work for their contractors; instead the contractors "can bring the agency to their next client". Did I just shoot myself in the foot? Would I still be able to file for UI? And since I did not call CA EDD to let them know my job status after I was laid off, is that claim still open?

Thanks Chris for your response.

Hi Carol,

I think I need some clarification for a thing or two.

After you started the freelancing(?) job, did you continue to collect partial benefits and report the earnings from the freelancing job?

And, when will your claim on the previous employment end .. or has it already ended? Although I am at present just a bit sketchy about work/share or short time compensation benefit programs .. I'll do some research between now and then.

Then we can move on to where I think the real problem may be.

Whether they call you a freelancer or an independent contractor .. what you sound like is is an "employee" and if so, it should be covered employment .. which just means they should not only be sending in your taxes to the IRS .. but matching SSI .. etc, and also be paying unemployment tax on what they are paying you .. and therein lies the problem ..

This sounds like an employer getting ready to tell the EDD you refused work .. if they are asked .. and they will be if you file for benefits.

Comments for Unusual Temp Agency and Unemployment Benefits

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Jan 18, 2011
Change in Detail
by: Carol

Chris, to answer your questions: 1) I didn't continue collecting partial benefits because my weekly freelancing earnings exceeded the $450 maximum UI benefits; 2) The workshare claim from my previous employer ends in June 2011.

I read the "suitable work" section and though there was no definite offer of full-time employment (the manager made that clear even before we both sat down to talk), she did say that her company could continue to use me as a freelancer typesetting manuals, which I had done at my previous employer, and now, at MC. Oddly, she did not offer to extend my freelance status since the production of these manuals was somewhat ongoing. In fact, she had asked my friend at 3 different times over the past 2 months, how long he would still need my help, and he would always say "at least for two more weeks". For me, what was unsuitable about the future "job" she described was that it consisted of just typesetting these manuals. And though, I could do it as a freelancer (because I was in "control" of my hours), as a full-time employee, I would've been miserable because there wasn't much variety to the projects I was given (in comparison to my previous employer.)

But I think the situation has gone from bad to worse, because out of curiosity, I asked my friend what he and his supe discussed. And he innocently told her I decided to end my assignment because I didn't want to do just manuals, day in and day out; which may have done more harm because I'm sure what he said will get back to the manager. So by opening my (big) mouth and letting him know what went on at the meeting; I essentially nailed my own skin to the wall.

Please note that I'm NOT for receiving UI. It makes me feel like I'm not capable of taking care of myself. But if someone really needs help, please be careful in what you say, and who you talk with. My friend is a decent guy, but he's not in my situation; and doesn't understand why it would make a difference who ended the freelance assignment.

Jan 17, 2011
Refusal of suitable work
by: Chris

I didn't publish your comment .. because you included a full name and I can't delete or alter names on comments ..

It's not a wise idea to include your full name on this site .. just in case ;; Some have learned this the hard way.

I think your assessment is right on .. but considering everything you told me .. keep your conversation with the EDD to the valid reason to refuse an offer of work that you might have.

I don't think most responsible people want to collect unemployment benefits .. Benefits are meant to be a temporary fix to a temporary problem to stabilize the economy .. and they are also inadequate at best when compared to a former paycheck.

I will even take a leap here and say that even those gaming the system in some way, would eventually begin to feel the weight of dragging around the ball and chain of benefits .. because they keep one personally tethered, to some fairly restrictive rules about what you can do while collecting.


Click here to add your own comments

Return to California Unemployment Questions.

} }